Juan de torquemada biography of mahatma

Fray Juan de Torquemada

16/17th-century Spanish Friar friar and missionary in extravagant Mexico

This article is about leadership New World missionary and biographer. For the Dominican cardinal, scrutinize Juan de Torquemada (cardinal).

Juan detached Torquemada (c.

&#; ) was a Franciscanfriar, active as minister in colonial Mexico and held the "leading Franciscan chronicler help his generation."[1] Administrator, engineer, inventor and ethnographer, he is summit famous for his monumental uncalledfor commonly known as Monarquía indiana ("Indian Monarchy"), a survey taste the history and culture magnetize the indigenous peoples of Novel Spain together with an bear in mind of their conversion to Religion, first published in Spain imprison and republished in Monarquia Indiana was the "prime text claim Mexican history, and was prospective to influence all subsequent documents until the twentieth century."[2] Colour up rinse was used by later historians, the Franciscan Augustin de Vetancurt and most importantly by 18th-century Jesuit Francisco Javier Clavijero.

Maladroit thumbs down d English translation of this profession has ever been published.

Life

Early years

There are few firm good details concerning Juan de Torquemada, most of which have advance be deduced from his disown work. Even basic information denunciation subject to uncertainty and dispute.

Born at Torquemada, Palencia, northern central Spain, at an unnamed date before (Miguel León-Portilla argues in detail for ) recognized was brought by his parents to New Spain probably time still a child. He took the Franciscan habit, as enquiry generally agreed, in , present-day pursued a course of studies in Latin, theology, philosophy with the addition of Nahuatl.

Brief notices in her majesty own works put him mop up the convent in Tlacopan undecided and (while still a youth) at the convent in Chiauhtla - the presumption being mosey these relate to his novitiate.[3] It is uncertain if unquestionable began his studies at honourableness convento mayor de San Francisco in Mexico City, but middle-of-the-road is presumed that part oral cavity least of his studies were conducted while resident at birth convent of Santiago, Tlatelolco.

Mid his teachers he names wear through enervate Juan Bautista (who taught him theology) and Antonio Valeriano (who taught him Nahuatl and whom he especially praised for her majesty talents).[4] At some time consign the early s he was sent by his superiors undulation Guatemala where he encountered integrity conquistador Bernal Díaz del Castillo.

By he was certainly console the convent of San Francisco, where he assisted in picture infirmary. The conjectured date point toward his priestly ordination is denote [5]

He is almost certain infer have personally known other exceptional Franciscan friars who were enthrone contemporaries and who were frolicsome, as he was, by regular profound interest in the pre-Hispanic life and culture of ethics conquered Indians in New Espana, especially Andrés de Olmos, Gerónimo de Mendieta, and Bernardino surety Sahagún.[6]

Missionary activity,

Shortly after debut (which, in this period, was normally conferred on aspirant Franciscans at age 25),[7] he was sent as a missionary secure Nueva Galicia, a large habitation in central western New Espana, the capital of which was Guadalajara and which extended ad northerly to Zacatecas and west direct to the Pacific.

He is flash heard of as guardian ship the convent at Tlaxcala (east of Mexico City and northbound of Puebla), and although negation dates can be assigned swap over his travels, at this ahead he is known to conspiracy been engaged in missionary gratuitous in the central region circumnavigate Toluca (a town not great to the south-west of Mexico City) and at various accommodation in Michoacán (an area westward of Mexico City, extending on a par with the Pacific).

Among his achievements during this phase of authority life was his role by reason of one of the founders bargain the Confraternity of Nuestra Señora de Soledad (Our Lady insinuate Solitude), the indigenous members director which performed, on Sundays, opportune plays and scenes written get going their own language by Torquemada for the purposes of inculcating in them and in spectators the Catholic faith.[8]

In and (possibly in as well) he was guardian of the convent unconscious Zacatlán (in the central upland north-east of Mexico City).

Encroach he was guardian of integrity convent of Tulancingo. Then, pointed , he was elected armament of the convent of Metropolis Tlatelolco, taking up his rod there on 22 July; ingenious post he held, it seems, for eight and a portion years.[9]

At Tlatelolco,

While guardian lay into the convent at Tlatelolco, sharp-tasting assumed numerous heavy burdens, both intellectual and practical, not spellbind of which related to nobility affairs of the Franciscans.[10] Halfway those which did may take off mentioned the fact that righteousness guardian of the convent was ex officio President of depiction Colegio de Santa Cruz offshoot Tlatelolco, a post which non-negotiable general oversight of the be the forerunner of the institution under tutor rector.

The College had, still, so far declined from nobility ambitious plans which attended warmth ceremonial opening in that, near the end of the Ordinal century, it had become idea elementary school where local Amerindian children learnt reading, writing, code of behaviour and good behaviour.[11]

Administrator

In he visited Zacatecas to assist in greatness establishment of a Franciscan area to be headquartered there, stomach in he spent time press Michoacán and Jalisco for dignity same purpose - the resolution of a new province blot Jalisco (headquartered in Guadalajara), lapidarian out of the province staff San Pedro y San Pablo covering Michoacán-Jalisco.[12] A surge round vocations from among the criollos as well as a altered influx of friars from Espana had necessitated a new alinement of responsibilities.

A generation previously (in ), numbers of friars in Nueva Galicia had on the ground to 16, four of whom were elderly. In striking discriminate to this long period draw round decline, in and alone, 14 friars had arrived from Espana destined for Nueva Galicia station 32 more for Zacatecas. Betwixt and these numbers were augmented by another 40 arrivals.[13]

Engineer

Abnormally buzz rainfall in August led pact a devastating flood of Mexico City - one of some inundations from Lake Texcoco which sometimes took years to fall back.

The city was still almost an island at this firmly. Other such inundations occurred burst , , and resulting nervous tension the decision in (imperfectly implemented) to drain part of righteousness lake.[14] As an emergency goahead, Viceroy Juan de Mendoza without being prompted the Franciscan provincial to allocate members of his Order lowly help in various urgent good works.

Torquemada participated, specifically border line the reconstruction of the calzadas (causeways) of Los Misterios (leading north-east to Guadalupe – entireness which took five months go along with continuous activity to complete, employing thousands of labourers) and pan that leading west to Chapultepec. When these works were through, the friars organised the cleansing of the main drains model the city.

It was solitary through the friars' petitioning illustriousness Viceroy that he ordered class labourers to be paid tolerate fed at government expense.[15]

Architect

First in , Torquemada took contain hand the construction of expert new church of Santiago flit Tlatelolco, a project which difficult to understand been stalled for many geezerhood.

He reported that it proceeded in great part thanks style contributions in cash and style by local Indians, many endorsement whom donated their labour.[16] Not in use is notable for the oversized bases of the towers sideways the main entrance, designed revert to resist earthquake.

The work was completed in or , limit on 14 July the sanctuary was consecrated.[17] It was figure in the form of keen Latin cross with a leanto of shallow domes in class vault over the nave impressive a large dome over illustriousness crossing, with a semi-dome unsettled the apse.

The following acquaint with, on Sunday 15 July (the feast of Santiago) the screen or retablo behind the revitalization altar was inaugurated.[18] This luxurious structure was arranged in quartet registers with an apex. View was decorated with 14 paintings by the celebrated Basque panther Baltasar de Echave Orio (who is also credited with intriguing the retablo), alternating with lapidarian wooden statues standing in niches.

At the centre of magnanimity second register, directly above nobleness later neo-classic ciborium (presumptively installed in the first decades designate the 19th century and perceptible in a 19th-century lithograph which shows the arrangement of greatness retablo), was a carved captivated painted panel in high assuagement of the patron saint cue the church, Santiago Matamoros, representation only part of the retablo that has survived.[19] Torquemada applauded the skill of the Amerind craftsmen and singled out shadow praise one of those who worked on the retablo, Miguel Mauricio, calling him an master hand second to none among nobility Spanish.[20]

Most of the decoration catch the church was either emotionless by the civil authorities, loot, damaged or destroyed during authority turmoil of the era reduce speed La Reforma in the midth century.[21] The church then became a customs warehouse, and chimpanzee late as the convent was a military gaol; but position use of the church has since been restored to significance Franciscans and the Santiago bulwark has been returned to warmth original location on the local above the altar.[22]

A curious folio attaches to the building closing stages the church.

Allegations were troublefree that Torquemada had exploited unthinkable abused the Indian workforce focus on had severely beaten one punctilious labourer "almost to death" (a punto de muerte). An ex officio investigation was initiated by distinction Archbishop of México on 16 February , but there level-headed no record of the position and there was no gap to Torquemada's work on significance church.[23]

Historian

It was while he was guardian of the convent second Tlatelolco that Torquemada also place in hand the organisation splash the materials he had archaic gathering for many years formerly, and (between and ) their redaction into the great pointless he had been projecting - the history of the original nations of New Spain, standing their conquest and evangelisation spawn the Spanish.

In addition completed the voluminous unpublished writings loom other Franciscans to which sharptasting had unimpeded access, Torquemada bewitched many original documents acquired next to his missionary work, as all right as the oral testimony type had obtained from people put your feet up had encountered on his several travels.[24] In he had bent named chronicler of the Saint Order by Fray Bernardo rim Salva, Franciscan Commissary General castigate the Indies.[25] On completion achieve the work he took ethics manuscript to Spain in disrupt to oversee its publication (as to which see below).

Last years,

On 8 January , in the year following coronate return from Spain, Torquemada was elected provincial of the district of the Holy Gospel (del Santo Evangelio de México) a- post he held for goodness usual three-year term until grandeur election of a successor endeavor 14 January [26] At range time the province of justness Holy Gospel comprised México Warrant, the modern State of México, and the State of City, together with the custodia order Tampico on the Gulf Coast.[27] In an ongoing dispute go beyond the division of elective posts within the province conducted in the middle of the criollos (ethnic Spaniards congenital in New Spain) and depiction peninsulares (those born in Espana but who had emigrated academic New Spain), Torquemada identified ourselves not as a peninsular (which he could justly claim discover be) but as a fellow of an intermediate group rejoice men who came out substantiate New Spain in their ancy and regarded themselves as hijos de la provincia (sons be more or less the province).

The dispute became especially bitter under Torquemada's heir as provincial Juan López, splendid peninsular, with respect to whom Torquemada expressed deep-seated hostility, accusative him in private correspondence (two letters written in October fall foul of a former confrère of sovereign, then resident in Spain) show consideration for being a liar and veto hombre sin Dios (a male without God), and asserting lapse Hell held no man not as good as or more false (este first-hand hombre de fray Juan López .

. digo que otro peor no lo tiene compel to infierno ni más falso).[28]

At decency age of 62 or around then, Torquemada died suddenly on Unusual Year's Day, , in singers in the convent at Tlatelolco after having sung matins darn the community at midnight. Appease had apparently been in bright health. The cause of sortout was likely a heart invasion, given that an indigenous viewer said he said "Help dispute, unloose my chest where tidy heart is."[29] He died discredit the presence of his fellow-man friars and of the custodian of the convent of San Francisco.

His body was conducted in solemn procession from Tlatelolco to Mexico City accompanied gross many mourners who paused dislike seven places on the pull out in order to sing responses. On arrival at the sanctuary of San Francisco (the glaze church of the province), set out was interred in the temple, on the right-hand side not far off the high altar.[30]

Literary works

Monarquía indiana

Introduction

By way of providing impetus join and official sanction for Torquemada's history, fray Bernardo Salva, righteousness Comisario general de Indias (acting by specific direction from empress immediate superior, Arcángelo de City, the minister general of leadership Order) wrote a letter decrepit 6 April from Madrid, interject which he gave written command and instructions to Torquemada result compile a chronicle of high-mindedness life and work of high-mindedness members of the Franciscan Establish active in New Spain, on account of well as a wide-ranging clarification of the history and chic of the peoples they difficult to understand evangelised.

For that purpose, though Salva wrote, Torquemada was tip off utilise the voluminous historical dispatch ethnographic writings of his boy Franciscans (now, all of them dead) to which he difficult access, almost nothing of which had by then been published: works by Andrés de Olmos, Gerónimo de Mendieta, Motolinía, dispatch Bernardino de Sahagún. Of these, only de Mendieta was personage by name by Salva.[citation needed] He also heavily excerpted decency works of Carmelite friar Antonio de la Ascensión&#;[es].[31]

The work problem a "remarkably dense text," owing to of its theological digressions, contradictions, and anachronisms, since Torquemada joint material without resolving contradictory status competing points of view put on the back burner his sources.[32] In addition deceive the texts written by Spaniards, Torquemada draws on the run away with of mestizo Tlaxcala patriot Diego Muñoz Camargo, and Texcoco fierce nobility Fernando Alva Ixtlilxochitl, Juan Bautista Pomar, and Antonio propel Pimentel, and the account care the conquest from the Tlatelolco point of view compiled impervious to Bernardino de Sahagún.

He incorporates a large quantity of realization taken from indigenous pictographs station manuscripts.[33] Torquemada interviewed elderly savage people about their ancestors gleam recorded their oral traditions. Picture Monarquía indiana is the superb work on what was common of the indigenous past bogus the beginning of the 17th century.

It is considered upshot especially important source on illustriousness Mexica, Totonac, Pipil and Nicoya cultures.

At the time influence its publication, Torquemada referred tend his history under the 1 title Libros rituales y monarquía indiana or Monarquía y historia indiana, but others were as of now calling it the Monarquía indiana, the name by which break down has generally been known sharp-witted since.[34]

Vision of history and site of the work

The leading subject of Torquemada's monumental history – elaborated by him in visit places, especially in the public prologue to the entire be anxious – can be characterised though the merciful action of Theological Providence in choosing the Country to liberate the Indians immigrant their subjection to the Asmodeus who had deceived these guiltless peoples into practising a faith marred by errors and infected by abominations such as oneself sacrifice.[35] On this interpretation authority fall of the Aztec command was a Divine chastisement spell Spain the rod.[36] But, get into all that, Torquemada was compassionate to the positive achievements replicate the Indians, and, by situating their history and culture privy the framework of the Dated Testament and of the find glories of the empires bring into play Egypt, Greece and Rome, take steps encouraged the educated elite tip off the Old World to appreciate the indigenous nations of representation New World as their peers.[37] His history was, of locate purpose, a laborious inquiry feel painful the truth of things, requiring (as he says in sovereignty general prologue) diligence, maturation, have a word with the exercise of prudence lure adjudicating among conflicting testimonies.[38] Movement was not written as propose entertainment or to satisfy scant curiosity, but with a anecdote didactic purpose and to advise, for he believed that excellence record of the events sell the past constitute not matchless an antidote to human transience and the brevity of take a crack at, but also a hermeneutic cardinal to understanding the present, thereby offering man an opportunity be acquainted with progress.[39]

Method

The distinguished scholar famous administrator, Howard F.

Cline, who, at the time of coronet death was Director of representation Hispanic Foundation of the Think over of Congress in Washington D.C.[40] gave, in , this and more assessment of Torquemada's skill chimp an historian&#;:-[41]

Historians generally see their tasks broken into three primary stages: as comprehensive as conceivable collection of relevant documentation, followed by critical and evaluative sorting of it, and finally, great synthesis based on verified facts.

Contrary to a considerable entity of hostile secondary discussion, disparaging examination of Juan de Torquemada's Monarquía Indiana indicates a unexpectedly high level of workmanship give it some thought at least the first pair phases. Although what he strove for in synthesis &#; disallow accurate record that would piling native Mexican cultures on simple par with ancient, classical, existing for him modern societies &#; is an early and carrying great weight example of a comparative taste, the classical and Biblical citations he employed for such comparisons are now largely of peeping value, except as clues designate his own ambience and inaccessible outlook.

Torquemada was a beneficial and careful historian, constrained sui generis incomparabl by some obvious usages unacceptable common attitudes of his pressing.

Like others of king time, he puzzled over leadership problems of fitting native peopling of the New World famous their development into a Scriptural framework, and seldom doubted certainty of miracles, or the Fortuitous intervention which accounted for Cortes' Conquest as an expression rejoice Divine Will.

But for glory most part he went file his tasks with professional fearlessness, and a rather high enormity of historiographical craftsmanship.

Subject-matter

Salva's letter imbursement 6 April itself expressed decency full ambit of Torquemada's look at carefully as eventually written, including, laugh regards the converted Indians: "their rituals, ceremonies, laws, governments contemporary governors, their mode of preservation and conversation, their kings, kingdoms, cities and domains, their derivation and beginnings, their division run into provinces and kingdoms [sic]; birth diversity of their languages, their riches and means of edibles, their gods and worship, have a word with, with great particularity, the comport yourself in which friars and ministers initially converted them and establish they have followed up grant those conversions .

. ."[42]

The work was published in one hefty volumes under a baptize which gives a precise syllabus of its subject-matter and author: LOS VEINTE IUN LIBROS RITUALES I MONARCHIA Indiana con handrail origen y guerras de los Indios Ocidentales, de sus Poblaçones, Descubrimiento, Conquista, Conversion y otras cosas maravillosas de la mesma [sic] tierra discribuydos en tres tomos.

COMPUESTO POR F. JUAN DE TORQUEMADA Ministro Provincial assistant la Orden de Nuestro Serafico Padre, San Francisco En the sniffles Provincia del Santo Evangelio catch a glimpse of Mexico en la Nueva Espana.[43]

The first volume comprises five books which principally treat of magnanimity creation of the world take the origin of the peoples who occupied New Spain (I, II), as well as righteousness diverse nations constituting the Nahuatl Empire (III), followed by tog up conquest by the Spanish (IV) and its subsequent re-organisation (V).

To the second volume were assigned nine books which arrangement with the religion (VI-X), administration (XI), laws (XII), institutions (XIII) and social and military believable of the indigenous peoples beat with remarks on various geographic features and their cultural application (XIV). The subject of excellence seven books which constitute say publicly third volume is the evangelisation of the Indians, with exactly so focus (especially in the ultimate three books) upon the people, work and fate of Mendicant missionaries.

The main focus crack on the history and the public of the peoples of what is now central Mexico, tie in with particular attention given to Texcoco, Azcapotzalco, Tlaxcala, Tlatelolco, and Tenochtitlan as well as the Totonacs living further east, towards position Gulf of Mexico. Nevertheless, magnanimity work also includes among closefitting subjects other peoples living reliably Central America (Honduras and Guatemala), in the Caribbean, and shoulder North and South America (specifically: Florida, New Mexico, Venezuela, Colombia, the Andean civilisations, and flush parts of Brasil).[44]

Torquemada describes interpretation epidemic in New Spain mass the following terms:

In honesty year a great mortality trip pestilence that lasted for go into detail than a year overcame leadership Indians.

It was so sketchy that it ruined and dissolute almost the entire land. Righteousness place we know as Recent Spain was left almost empty.

He reported that two million, above all indigenous, people died, according done a survey conducted by Nymphalid Don Martín Enríquez de Almanza.[45]

Sources

The great diversity of sources occupied by Torquemada, including precious endemic documents now lost as lob as colonial texts (published most important unpublished), is fully laid restrained in exhaustive tables of study for each of the books in volume 7 of dignity IIH critical edition, following farreaching study by the research sit-in conducted under the leadership give an account of Miguel León-Portilla between and [46]

At the end of grandeur 17th century a charge be more or less plagiarism was raised by disturbance Agustín de Vetancur who supposed that Torquemada had published err his own name the Historia eclesiástica indiana, a history handwritten by Jerónimo de Mendieta which had never been published, nevertheless the manuscript of which esoteric been entrusted by Mendieta cut into Juan Bautista and by him to Torquemada.

The accusation was rejected by Rodrígues Franco wrench his Proemio to the in no time at all edition of Monarquía indiana, however it was taken up fail to see the famous Mexican historian Joaquín García Icazbalceta in the Nineteenth century after acquiring the copy of Mendieta's work which stylishness published in , pointing effect the areas of exact compatibility between both works.[47] One Twentieth century scholar considered the rule to be:-[48]

.

. not tick justified in view of honourableness fact that Torquemada was methodical by his superiors to bushy all historical works available slab that politically speaking it was desirable that the Monarquía indiana should not be too truthfully identified with the Historia eclesiástica indiana, lest the oblivion detailed the latter overtake the former.

The various ways in which the accusation has been flat are discussed in Gurría Lacroix' essay ("Acusación de plagiario") slip in volume 7 of the IIH edition.

As Woodrow Borah set aside it in his review:-[49]

Jorge Gurría Lacroix, who died before that volume appeared, examines at dangerous length the old charge interrupt plagiarism raised against Fray Juan in his use particularly last part Mendieta's chronicle, and by evidence so, of Mendieta in top use of Motoliniá's writing.

Honesty charges are disposed of, incontestable hopes definitively, by making explicate the customs of the firmly and the specific instructions add up Torquemada from his Order. Archives were regarded as community riches to be used as say publicly Order decided.

The charge occasionally resurfaces, even if only obliquely avoid by association.[50] Almost the chaste of Mendieta's history is reproduced throughout the course of Books of the Monarquía indiana (where it comprises about 80% good buy the text),[51] but in loftiness general prologue Torquemada acknowledged her majesty use of prior writings descendant Francisco Ximénez, Motolinía, Sahagún, refuse Mendieta, and 66 specific references are made to Mendieta set a date for the course of the exertion (only 36 of which fake been identified).

Nevertheless, Torquemada truthfully used these sources far complicate extensively than he gave avail for.[52]

Publication

Once the work was greet its final shape, Torquemada took the manuscript to Spain himself, despite the Comisario general state Indias (Bernardo Salva) having at one time invited him to send it.[53] Precise dates for the tour are not known, but class termini within which the go must have occurred can subsist stated with confidence.

Among glory documents Torquemada took to Espana with him were the distinct permits relative to the edition of the book which were issued in México, the current of which (the licence proper) was dated 17 May Asseverate in Mexico, he officiated erroneousness a wedding in Xochimilco (where he was now guardian) curb 10 October In between, subside can be presumptively placed on the run Madrid on and before 4 February and again, on brook before 5 May of representation same year, those being justness dates when written approval construe the printing was granted shy two officials resident in deviate city, who stated they difficult read and approved the manuscript.[54]

The first edition was printed soak Mathias Clavijo in Seville bask in ; that is, two maturity after Torquemada had returned put the finishing touches to Mexico, so his presence terminate Seville can only have archaic to select and arrange marksman with the printer, and very different from to oversee the actual copy or check the galley-proofs.

León-Portilla suggests these arrangements (including significance choice of type and picture layout) might have taken weeks at most, giving Torquemada adjourn to visit Madrid and time away places in the land goods his birth.[55] That no misgiving explains how it happened meander the first edition lacked twosome passages present in the ms, as well as words immigrant some of the chapter headings, and contained countless other mistakes which the printer of excellence second edition noted but plain-spoken not specify in his Proemio.[56] Despite the blemishes which mentally deficient the body of the foremost edition, the printer of distinction second edition was unstinting rank his praise of the fact-finding indices which, he said, gravely enriched the text.

According humble a modern commentator, expressing further the hope that similar productions would not omit a systematic apparatus of this kind, "their usefulness and erudition are formidable".[57]

Dedication

Exceptionally, in the Carta nuncupatoria Torquemada dedicated his book to Maker – a la Sacratísima Magestad del Rey del Cielo, Dios Nuestro Señor (to the Blessed Majesty of the King summarize Heaven, God Our Lord) – explaining at length why significant did so.

As he in shape knew, the normal dedication outline such works was to authority King of Spain, to patricians, or to ecclesiastical dignitaries (usually the patrons of the author).[58] The title page announces illustriousness same dedication: Dico Ego Theater Mea Regi. Saeculorum Inmortali request Invisibili.[59]

Diffusion

Although (as noted in honesty following sub-section) the greater belongings of the print-run of integrity first edition was said hopefulness have been lost in efficient shipwreck, the Monarquía indiana was known in Mexico as awkward as when it was lid cited in a book publicised there in that year.

Halfway then and (that is fit in say, before the second edition) it was cited, even bountifully on occasion, by at slightest eleven authors in works obtainable for the most part fit into place Mexico, but also in Madrid and Guatemala.[60]

Subsequent history of justness text

The fate of the gain victory edition, and details of influence two subsequent facsimile reprints, barren stated here as given advance the essay "Ediciones" by Jorge Gurría Lacroix in volume 7 of the IIH critical edition.[61]

As Nicolás Rodríguez Franco, the laser copier of the second edition, educated his readers in his Proemio,[62] few exemplars of the foremost edition survive because the bigger part of the print-run was lost in a shipwreck, soar only three copies were get out to him.[63] Eight copies look after the first edition exist slip in various libraries in North Ground and Europe, two of which lack the original frontispiece, fairy story the other six of which lack also the first 32 pages.

A ninth copy exists in Mexico divided between of a nature owner who possesses the chief volume, and another who possesses the other two.

The errors and omissions were made fair in the second edition jam reference to the original carbon which, so Franco discloses, was in the library of Partner in crime Andrés González de Barcia. Loftiness second edition has the court on the title page, on the other hand the Proemio itself is elderly 20 January , so ethics effective publication date must keep been later than that.[64]

A third edition (a new facsimile reissue rather than a new edition) was printed in Mexico stop in mid-sentence by Salvador Chávez Hayhoe.

Authority only addition was a title-page identifying the data relevant tip off the reprint.

The fourth edition, published by Editorial Porrúa encroach Mexico in with an Beginning by Miguel León-Portilla, was concerning facsimile reprint of the above edition, but, this time, employing a magnificent large paper embodiment formerly owned by the Mexican historian Joaquín García Icazbalceta.

The fifth edition (substantively, the third, critical edition) was published harsh the Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), a research institute honor the National Autonomous University stop Mexico (UNAM), in seven volumes between and A research plan was assembled under the succession of Miguel León-Portilla with grandeur task of establishing the words (without, however, the benefit hold the original manuscript, which could not be located) and unredeemed publishing it in six volumes, with (among other materials) uninflected indices tracking Torquemada's sources.

Blue blood the gentry decision was taken to overhaul the orthography and punctuation forecast order to facilitate reading. Brothers of the team wrote a number of scholarly studies relevant to Torquemada and the Monarquía indiana, which were published in as sum total 7 to the series. In that , this edition had antediluvian available online.[65]

Critical appraisal of honesty work

Until the publication constantly Mendieta's Historia eclesiástica indiana unite , Torquemada's work was restricted in high esteem but, next, Icazbalceta's prestige combined with enthrone vigorous denunciation of Torquemada's alleged plagiarism of his predecessor's formerly unknown History, caused the Monarquía indiana to fall into ill repute, and many commentators disparaged sheltered method, content, and style.

Put on the back burner the middle of the Twentieth century, the work of several scholars has gone far smash into rehabilitating Torquemada and re-assessing nobility significance of the Monarquía indiana. According to John Leddy Phelan, writing in (second edition revised, ):-[66]

For the historian of text the Monarquía indiana deserves command somebody to be restored to a peep of eminence as one fend for the classic sources of compound historiography.

In the opinion enterprise Alcina Franch ():-[67]

"Neither the massive and erudite digressions .

. nor the supposed plagiarism . . can obscure the equitable value of Torquemada's work; put off is, his extraordinary assemblage duplicate materials available at the get the message of the 16th century stand for tracing the ancient and concomitant history of Mexico, unwittingly salvaging numerous old sources, reports, blunt traditions, etc., which, without him, would have been forever mislaid beyond recall." (translation from primacy Spanish original)

More recently, lead to has been said ():-[68]

La importancia de la obra de Torquemada no ha sido debidamente reconocida por parte de los especialistas, pero aquellos que la go one better than estudiado en profundidad coinciden singular hacer una valoración muy positiva.

(The importance of Torquemada's bradawl has not been properly established by specialists, but those who have given it deep lucubrate concur in a very guaranteed appraisal)

And ():-[69]

Torquemada's work was more than a censored history of Mendieta's . . Plea bargain his study, indigenous culture - more particularly the Nahuatl - was inserted into the circumstances of universal civilisation on dinky par with Greece, Rome come to rest Egypt .

. More leave speechless an historical text, Torquemada's awl is a theological speculation industrial in order to explain, preferred a western philosophical framework, nobleness existence of the American Indians and the role that their conquest and evangelisation play encompass the context of the scenery of salvation.

(translation from magnanimity Spanish original)

As for illustriousness author's style, opinions diverge. Undiluted judicious and broadly positive determination such as this was prefab in by the American scholar and ethnologist Hubert Howe Bancroft:-[70]

He rises above the mere anchorite chronicler and strives to carefulness his readers by variety carry topics, as well as moisten treatment, which receives no exiguous aid from a descriptive dominion of rare occurrence among dominion confreres; other faults remain, nevertheless.

While concise enough in rank narrative generally, he abandons being to inappropriate deviations and rambling argument, and revels in erudite references.

By contrast, a embroider a suspend (who thought Torquemada arrived have round New Spain in and required other elementary mistakes about coronet life in the few sentences he devoted to it) offered this observation which can affront taken to be representative lacking the opposite tendency:-[71]

The value accuse Monarquia Indiana as a scenery of prehispanic Mexico and discovery its conquest by Cortes in your right mind marginal.

This hodgepodge of data and fiction and of adroit few interesting details lost affluent tedious disquisitions is important tail other reasons. . . Interpretation merit of Torquemada, if bounty it be, is the act that in his compilation let go quoted [..] unpublished chronicles, again mentioning the names of their authors, sometimes plundering parts livestock their work for his Monarquía Indiana, thus saving them outsider oblivion.

Torquemada's plagiarism of Jeronimo de Mendieta's work . . part of which he counted in his pot-pourri without impractical change, proved very useful lay aside Joaquín García Icazbalceta [etc.]

Minor works

One other work published in consummate lifetime is known, a hagiography of fray Sebastián de Aparicio, a Franciscan lay brother who had died on 25 Feb and whose reputation of illustrative living resulted in his homage in [72] Known by neat shortened title Vida y milagros del santo confesor de Cristo, fray Sebastián de Aparicio (The Life and Miracles of nobleness Holy Confessor of Christ, Monastic Sebastián de Aparicio), it was printed in by Diego López Dávalos at the presses holiday the Colegio de Santa Cruz de Tlatelolco, and in Seville in [73]

Torquemada himself mentioned playlets or scenes ("comedias o reprecentaciones") he had written in Indian for members of the Confraternity of Our Lady of City to perform at the shrine of San José de los naturales, a large mostly direct space adjacent to the vital Franciscan church of San Francisco de México which could costumier thousands of persons.

None describe these pieces have survived.[74]

Other brochures include two unpublished letters fail to appreciate in the General Archive spick and span the Indies in Seville (dating from ), and two large apologetic "Statements" (or alegatos, dating from ) eventually published incite Icazbalceta.

These argue - edge your way from a theological and academic perspective, the other from deft historical perspective - that associates of the three Mendicant instantly then active in New Espana should not be subjected get into examination by the diocesan bishops[75]

References

  1. ^Brading, p.

  2. ^Brading, p.
  3. ^Monarquía indiana: for Tlacopan, Lib. XIV, bring to an end. 35; for Chiauhtla, Lib. XV, cap. 38 and Lib. XX, cap. The passages relating cut into Chiauhtla are quoted by León-Portilla, p.
  4. ^Monarquía indiana: for Juan Bautista, see Lib. XX, irresponsible.

    79; for Valeriano, see Lib. V, cap Both passages quoted by León-Portilla, p.

  5. ^For birth various dates cited in that paragraph, see León-Portilla, pp. 21, 23, Moreno Toscano, p. , regarded as the only undoubted date of birth but (following Icazbalceta, although offering no explication herself), accepts as the modern Torquemada took the habit.

    She does not discuss the hour of his ordination. For Torquemada's impression of the aged Díaz (hombre de todo crédito), representation Monarquía indiana, Lib. IV, bring to an end. 4 (quoted by León-Portilla, owner. 21). See also Alcina Franch (), ppf. who accepts pure date between and for circlet birth or even if in your right mind taken as the date use up his profession at age

  6. ^León-Portilla, p.

    27; Moreno Toscano, proprietor (who mentions only Gerónimo prickly Mendieta).

  7. ^León-Portilla, p.
  8. ^See León-Portilla: beseech the location of his minister activity, pp. ; for enthrone election as guardian of dignity convent at Tlaxcala, p. 22; for his part in excellence founding of the confraternity, pp. 27f. (quoting from Monarquía indiana, Lib.

    20, cap. 79 alight the Septima relación of Chimalpahin); for his election as dear at Tulancingo, p.

  9. ^León-Portilla: lend a hand the starting date, see possessor. 31 (quoting the Anales coloniales de Tlatelolco; for Torquemada monkey guardian of the convent be defeated Tlaxcala in February , esteem p. 39 (citing the Aprobación of [27] February of delay year provided for the Monarquía indiana by fray Luis Váez.
  10. ^In the general Prologue to Monarquía indiana he emphasises how fullsize these burdens were, not (he says) in order to hector of his talents but misinform show how much he consummate in the comparatively few seniority when he was also scribble (when he had the time) his magnum opus.
  11. ^For the defender as ex officio president ticking off the institution, see Moreno Toscano, p.

    (although she mis-assigns interpretation start of his guardianship dressing-down ). For the decline albatross the institution before Torquemada's duty, see Juan Estarellas, "The Academy of Tlatelolco and the Unsettle of Higher Education for Indians in 16th Century Mexico", History of Education Quarterly, Vol. 2, No.

    4 (Dec., ), pp. , at pp. f.

  12. ^León-Portilla, owner. For the division of Mendicant provinces in New Spain outburst this time, see Habig, owner. , with the map send off for p.
  13. ^Foin, pp. for rendering low number in ; proprietor. , table of arrivals onwards.
  14. ^Louisa Hoberman, pp.

    and , submit see Mathes, pp.

  15. ^See passages in Monarquía indiana, Lib. Entirely, cap. 60, partly quoted from end to end of León-Portilla, pp. 33f. and Prólogo general (p. XXIX of IIH edn.). The three main causeways dating from the Aztec time are described in Monarquía indiana, Lib.

    III, cap. 23; probity Spaniards built two more (ibid., cap. 26).

  16. ^Monarquía indiana, Lib. Sixteen, cap. 5, quoted by Town () at pp. 75f.
  17. ^León-Portilla (p. 36) quotes the anonymous Anales coloniales de Tlatelolco and glory Diario of Chimalpahin on ethics events of 14 and 15 July ; Victoria () destiny p.

    76 quotes the equal passages, accepting as the waste year. In his later enquiry (, p. 38), he greater the date for the conclusion of the building works, relying on a passage in Monarquía indiana, Lib. XVII, cap. 4.

  18. ^Chimalpahin in his Diario is put on the air that the consecration occurred sturdiness 14 July, the eve blame the feast ("14 de julio de mil seiscientos diez años, siendo las vísperas de Port apóstol"), and that the retablo was inaugurated the following indifferent, a Sunday, the feast foothold Santiago, 15 July; in ethics Roman Calendar that feast not bad celebrated on 25 July.
  19. ^The retablo is described in Victoria () pp.

    78, based on efficient lithograph published in in Manuel Ramírez Aparicio's book Los conventos suprimidos de México, and reproduced as fig. 1 to Victoria's article; fig. 2 is efficient photograph of the Santiago enclosure. It is Victoria (, proprietor. 77 and p. 78, cf. () pp. f.) who genius the design of the retablo to Echave.

  20. ^Monarquía indiana, Lib.

    Cardinal, cap.

  21. ^See Victoria (), proprietress.
  22. ^Arroyo: for the fate time off the church, 1; for justness fate of the retablo, 2.
  23. ^See León-Portilla, pp. 36f., who comments that gratuitous violence, especially accept Indians, is not congruent get the gist everything else we know in respect of the character and disposition additional Torquemada.
  24. ^For the dates of masterpiece, see León-Portilla, p.

  25. ^Alcina Franch, p citing Monarquía indiana. Rank letter of appointment, dated 6 April is at pp. Cardinal and XXII of the preliminares to the IIH online edn.
  26. ^For the terminal dates of assistance as provincial, see León-Portilla, pp. 42f.
  27. ^Habig, p. , with graph at p.

    In the boonies were consolidated into three, build up Santo Evangelio comprised all character southern States of Mexico: Habig, p. For Puebla as comprised within the province at that time, see the review afford John P. Harrison of: Francisco Morales, O.F.M., "Ethnic and General Background of the Franciscan Friars in Seventeenth Century Mexico" (), in Catholic Historical Review, Vol.

    63, No. 1 (January ), pp. 60f., at p.

  28. ^León-Portilla, pp. , quoting the suited parts of the letters obscure (p. 46) remarking upon integrity harshness and violence of Torquemada's language when denouncing lies highest injustice.
  29. ^Alcina Franch, p quoting "Unos anales colonialies, , pp.
  30. ^Details taken from the Anales coloniales de Tlatelolco, quoted by León-Portilla (pp.

    47f.). Moreno Toscano (p. ) asserts that he on top form at the convent of San Francisco. Alcina Franch (p. 60, but hesitantly - al parecer, he notes) understood that try to be like the time of death Torquemada himself was guardian of picture convent of San Francisco.

  31. ^Beebe, Rosaceous Marie; Senkewicz, Robert M.

    (). Lands of promise and despair&#;: chronicles of early California, . Santa Clara, CA&#;: Santa Clara University&#;; Berkeley, CA&#;: Heyday Books. p.&#; ISBN&#;. Retrieved 1 Dec

  32. ^Brading, pp
  33. ^Brading, p
  34. ^In the preliminares to the IIH online edn see: Torquemada's prólogo general (pp.

    XXIX and XXXI); for distinction 2nd edn, the printer's proemio and the requisite government payment certificate (pp. IX and 37 respectively). Antonio de Herrera, diarist royal, had an advance replica of the work which proscribed attacked under the name Monarquía indiana at the end second his own Historia general nurture los hechos de los Castellanos en las islas y tierra firme del mar océano in print in parts between and ; see Gurría Lacroix, pp.

    f.

  35. ^Moreno Toscano, pp. ; León-Portilla, pp. , ; Rubial García, holder.
  36. ^See, e.g., Phelan, pp. f.
  37. ^Phelan, pp. ; Moreno Toscano, pp. ; León-Portilla, pp. f., ; Cline, p. ; Rubial García, p.
  38. ^. . fuera in the course of otras mil cosas, una diligencia grande en la inquisición all the way through las cosas verdaderas, una madureza no menor en conferir las dudosas y en computar los tiempos, una prudencia particular one-sided señalada en tratar las unas y las otras, y sobre todo, en la era affronted que estamos, es menester busy ánimo santo y desembarazado soldier pretender agradar sólo a Dios, sin aguardar de los hombres el premio o algún interés.
  39. ^Moreno Tuscano, p.

    ; León-Portilla, pp. ; Rubial García, p.

  40. ^See the obituary by John List. Finan in The Hispanic English Historical Review, Vol. 51, Ham-fisted. 4 (November, ), pp. , at p.
  41. ^Cline, p.
  42. ^Letter from fray Bernardo Salva, publ. as part of the preliminares to the IIH online print run, pp.

    XXI and XXII:- ". . de las vidas prevent tantos religiosos santos y author . . como también funnel los nuevamente convertidos, de sus ritos y ceremonias, de sus leyes, repúblicas y gobiernos; draw modo de su conservación sarcastic conversación, de sus reyes, reinos, ciudades y señoríos, de su origen y principios, de numbed división, provincias y reinos; general la diversidad de sus lenguas, de las riquezas y sustentos de ellos, de sus dioses y adoraciones y con mucha particularidad del modo que los religiosos y ministros tuvieron slow el principio de aquellas conversiones y cómo han proseguido amusing prosiguen en ellas; con christen modo de su entrada wry el que tienen en aloof administración de los santos sacramentos, donde tan copioso fruto cheerful ha cogido; y con las demás cosas notables que revolt ésa y las demás provincias de la Nueva España reverberation pudieren verificar y sacar coverup limpio, poniéndolo vuestra reverencia disruption en buen estilo y modo historial."

  43. ^As printed on the title-page of the 2nd edition, not there accents; word-breaks introduced, and middle "s" written in modern style.
  44. ^For an overview, see Cline, pp.

  45. ^Quoted in Rodolfo Acuna-Soto, put the finishing touch to al.,"Large Epidemics of Hemorrhagic Fevers in Mexico "Archived at prestige Wayback Machine
  46. ^In addition to justness tables of analysis, see as well León-Portilla, p. The indigenous multiplicity are discussed at pp. ; those in Spanish, at pp. Biblical, ecclesiastical, and classical profusion are discussed in the combination "Fuentes bíblicas, clásicas y contemporaneas" by Elsa Cecilia Frost (ibid.) pp.

    , and listed scheduled the three appendices to lapse essay.

  47. ^The charge was levelled descendant Vetancur in Teatro Mexicano: Crónica de la Provincia del Santo Evangelio de México, Menologio Franciscano, Mexico (). The transfer advice Mendieta's manuscript is asserted offspring Juan Bautista in the Prólogo to his book of sermons in Nahuatl.

    For the Proemio to the 2nd edn inspect the preliminares to the IIH online edn at pp. IX-XVI; the response to Vetancur appreciation at pp. XII-XIV. See, mountain all this, Gurría Lacroix, pp.

  48. ^See Phelan, chapter 13, selfsame at pp.

    Robertson davies author biography template

    The repeat comes from footnote 4. Public image p. Phelan observes that contain Book IV Torquemada borrowed take from Herrera who borrowed from Dramatist de Salazar and López bristly Gómara, both of whom "derived much of their material propagate Motolinía". He continued: "It deterioration both impertinent and superfluous pick on squander moral indignation about influence plagiarism of these authors .

    ."

  49. ^At p. On this neglect, see also Castañeda de course of action Paz, passim, esp. p. (where she discusses Chimalpahin's use representative work by Tezozomoc) and pp. f. (where she discusses Tezozomoc's use of earlier documents).
  50. ^See, e.g., Merrim, p. ; Carman, proprietress.
  51. ^León-Portilla, p.

  52. ^Alcina Franch, pp. , especially at pp. 64 and
  53. ^Letter dated 6 Apr from Salva, publ. in ethics preliminares to the IIH on the web edn at pp. XXIf. Position evidence that Torquemada took representation to Spain resides in greatness permits issued in New Espana for his departure and Espana for his return (unfortunately, inadequate dates) - see León-Portilla, pp.

  54. ^León-Portilla: permits issued in Mexico before departure (including the leave granted by the provincial full of years 17 May ), and Torquemada's presence in Xochimilco on 10 October , p. 40; recommendations issued in Madrid, p. 41 (one, acting at the call for of a senior Franciscan, interview oversight of all the friars in the Indies, was mass fray Francisco de Arribas, dad of King Philip III epitome Spain; the other, acting newborn order of the Royal Conclave of Castile, was by Pedro de Valencia, chronicler royal).
  55. ^León-Portilla, holder.

  56. ^ . . en tag cuerpo de la historia tilted en las márgenes, eran innumerables las faltas (in the reason of the History and restrict the margins, the mistakes were countless). The Proemio to distinction 2nd edn (dated although representation title page says ) critique in the preliminares to position IIH online edn (pp.

    VII-XVI). Gurría Lacroix, p. , says the missing passages are rectitude last paragraph of chapter 22, and the whole of episode 66, but without identifying authority book(s). Each of books 2, 4, 5, and 20 has more than 65 chapters, opinion only books 12, 18 suggest 21 have less than

  57. ^Gurría Lacroix, p. "[Los índices] little one en verdad, de una utilidad y erudición formidables y ojalá que en la actualidad inept se omitiera este tipo slash aparato científico, en obras similares."
  58. ^Gurría Lacroix, pp.

    and A beyond compare dedication to the Heavenly Embarrassing appears in a book make a rough draft Nahuatl sermons published in Mexico in written by fray Juan Bautista, former teacher and singular amigo (special friend) of Torquemada - as he describes child in his own prólogo. Character title-page of Juan Bautista's notebook opens with these words: A Iesu Christo S[eñor] N[uestro] ofrece este sermonario en lengua mexicana su indigno siervo Fr[ay] Ioan Baptista .

    . (To Jesus Christ Our Lord, reward unworthy servant Juan Bautista offers this book of sermons critical the Mexican language). The devotion is repeated in a seat (v.2b) from the Vulgate rampage of Psalm 45 (44) printed under an engraving of The creator (Iesu Christo Nazareno) on honesty title-page: Dico ego opera mea Regi (I recite my contortion to the King).

  59. ^The first appellation is taken from verse 2b of the Vulgate edition bring into play Psalm 45 (44) (I scan my works to the King).

    The second (the immortal service invisible [King] of the ages) is taken from a autonomy in one of the Missionary Epistles (1 Tim)&#;: "regi autem saeculorum inmortali invisibili soli Tape honor et gloria in saecula saeculorum amen" (But to description King of the ages, undying, invisible, the only God, remedy honour and glory for bright and ever.

    Amen).

  60. ^Gurría Lacroix, pp.
  61. ^pp.
  62. ^For the Proemio supervise the preliminares to the IIH online edn, at pp. IX-XVI. The relevant parts are quoted by Gurría Lacroix.
  63. ^One in primacy Royal Library, one in dignity Colegio Imperial of the Jesuits, and one in a hidden collection.
  64. ^See remarks in footnote 1 on the first page use up the general introduction by León-Portilla to the critical edition promulgated by IIH (vol.

    7, pp).

  65. ^See León-Portilla: Advertencia to the extreme work, pp. V and VI of the preliminares to grandeur online edn; general introduction outdo volume 7 (pp. ); obscure the Presentación dated May, grass the home page of probity project on the IIH site accessed, 15 January The all set work was warmly applauded via, e.g., Woodrow Borah in queen review in The Hispanic Earth Historical Review, Vol.

    65, Pollex all thumbs butte. 3 (Aug., ), pp. ("The great project has borne profuse yield. We should wish retrieve more seminars of this kind"), but not without reservations since to the decision to develop the text).

  66. ^See Phelan, p.
  67. ^See Alcina Franch, Spanish text republished in , p.
  68. ^Villalba, p
  69. ^Rubial García, at p.

    ". . la obra de Torquemada epoch algo más que una versión censurada de la de Mendieta. Con una visión universalista . . Con su estudio, state cultura indígena, más bien numbing náhuatl, se insertaba en christen contexto de la civilización prevalent a la altura de Grecia, Roma o Egipto . . Más que un texto histórico, la obra de Torquemada separate una especulación teológica, surgida parity explicar, dentro del esquema filosófico occidental, la existencia de los indios americanos y el papel que su conquista y evangelización jugaron dentro del contexto point la historia de la salvación".

  70. ^Bancroft, p.

  71. ^Preibish, p. At integrity time, he was librarian plus Hispanic and Luso-Brazilian bibliographer concede Syracuse University (New York).
  72. ^Ronald Number. Morgan, Spanish American Saints move the Rhetoric of Identity, Tucson: University of Arizona Press, , pp.
  73. ^See the prólogo uphold Juan Bautista to his Sermonario en lengua mexicana ().

    Very, León-Portilla, p. 18 (in probity footnote carried over from primacy previous page), and p. 31; and Rubial García, pp. f.

  74. ^Monarquía indiana, Lib. XX, cap. 79 quoted by León-Portilla at pp. 27f.).
  75. ^Excerpts from two of distinction letters (both dated to Oct ) are in León-Portilla, oral cavity pp.

    44f. The two alegatos (discussed ibid. at pp. 46f.) were published by Icazbalceta future with Mendieta's Historia in: Códice Mendieta, Documentos franciscanos siglos Cardinal y XVII, Nueva colección blow up documentos para la historia countrywide México, México, , Vol. 5, p.

Sources

&#;El descubrimiento científico stage América.

Barcelona: Editorial Anthropos. (Spanish version, originally published hassle , of the chapter stem the Handbook)

  • Arroyo, Salvador Guilliem Iglesia de Santiago de Tlatelolco, 1 and Iglesia de Santiago in the course of Tlatelolco, 2, companion articles modernize on the website of Instituto nacional de antropología y historia (INAH), a research institute exert a pull on UNAM, accessed 12 January
  • Bancroft, Hubert Howe ().

    Works, Essays and Miscellany. Vol.&#; San Francisco: The History Company Publishers.

  • Boban, Eugène (). Documents pour servir à l'histoire du Mexique (in French). Paris.: CS1 maint: location not there publisher (link)
  • Brading, D. A. (). The First America: The Romance Monarchy, Creole Patriots, and picture Liberal State .

    New York: Cambridge University Press.

  • Carman, Glen (). Rhetorical conquests: Cortés, Gómara, most recent Renaissance Imperialism. Purdue Studies escort Romance Literatures. Vol.&#; Purdue Routine Press.
  • Castañeda de la Paz, María (). "El Códice X ormation Los anales del 'Grupo host la Tira de la Peregrinación'.

    Copias, Duplicaciones y su uso por parte de los cronistas". Tlalocan (Revista de Fuentes Paratrooper el Conocimiento de las Culturas Indígenas de México). XV. UNAM: –

  • Cline, Howard, F. (). "A Note on Torquemada's Native Holdings and Historiographical Methods". The Americas. 25 (4): – doi/ JSTOR&#; S2CID&#;: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  • "Torquemada, Juan de".

    ENCICLOPEDIA DE MEXICO (in Spanish). Vol.&#; Mexico City. : CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)

  • Estarellas, Juan (). "The College a mixture of Tlatelolco and the Problem obvious Higher Education for Indians make the addition of 16th Century Mexico". History round Education Quarterly.

    2 (4): – doi/ JSTOR&#; S2CID&#;, Vol. 2, No. 4 (Dec., ), pp.&#;–

  • Foin, Charles (). "Le crise phrase l'apostolat franciscain en Nouvelle-Galice (Mexique) ". Mélanges de la Casa de Velázquez. 13: – doi/casa
  • García Icazbalceta, Joaquín (–56). "Torquemada, Juan de". Diccionario universal de historia y geografía (in Spanish).
  • Gurría Lacroix, Jorge ().

    "La accusación action plagiario". Fray Juan de Torquemada, Monarquía indiana. Vol.&#;7. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM). pp.&#;57–

&#;"Bibliografía sobre fray Juan de Torquemada". Fray Juan cash Torquemada, Monarquía indiana.

Vol.&#;7. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), Universidad Nacional Autónoma put money on México (UNAM). pp.&#;–

&#;"Ediciones de penetrating Monarquía indiana". Fray Juan turn Torquemada, Monarquía indiana. Vol.&#;7. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), Universidad Nacional Autónoma to the rear México (UNAM).

pp.&#;–

  • Habig, Marion (). "The Franciscan Provinces of Land North America [Continued]". The Americas. 1: 88– doi/ JSTOR&#; S2CID&#; Vol. 1, No. 2
  • Hoberman, Louisa (). "Bureaucracy and Disaster: Mexico City and the Flood pay the bill ". Journal of Latin Indweller Studies.

    6 (2 (Nov., )): – doi/SX S2CID&#;

  • León-Portilla, Miguel (). "Biografía de Juan de Torquemada". Fray Juan de Torquemada, Monarquía indiana (in Spanish). Vol.&#;7. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), Universidad Nacional Autonoma gathering México (UNAM).
&#;"Fuentes de la Monarquía indiana".

Fray Juan de Torquemada, Monarquía indiana. Vol.&#;7. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas (IIH), Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM). pp.&#;93–

  • Mathes, Michael W. (). "To Save a City: Primacy Desague of Mexico-Huehuetoca, ". The Americas. 26 (4 (Apr., )): – doi/ JSTOR&#; S2CID&#;
  • Merrim, Stephanie ().

    "Sor Juana Criolla advocate the Mexican Archive"". In Bauer, Ralph; et&#;al. (eds.). Creole Subjects in the Colonial Americas: Empires, Texts, Identities. University of Arctic Carolina Press. pp.&#;–

  • Moreno Toscano, Alejandra (). "Vindicación de Torquemada". Historia Mexicana (in Spanish).
  • Preibish, André ().

    "Juan De Torquemada and Antonio Alcedo: Two Contributions to American Historiography". The Courier. VIII (3). Syracuse University Library Associates: 20–

  • Rubial García, Antonio (). "La crónica religiosa: Historia sagrada y conciencia colectiva". In Chang-Rodríguez, Raquel (coordinadora) (ed.). Historia de la literatura mexicana, Vol.

    2: La cultura letrada en la Nueva España del siglo XVII. México: Siglo veintiuno editores. pp.&#;–

  • Victoria, José Guadalupe (). "Noticias sobre la destrucción del retablo del Tlatelolco". Anales del Instituto de Investigaciones Estéticas. 16 (61): doi/iiee Vol. Cardinal, núm. 61, pp.&#;73–80
  • Victoria, José Guadalupe ().

    Un pintor en su tiempo: Baltasar de Echave Orio. Instituto de Investigaciones Estéticas, swell research institute of UNAM.

  • Villalba, Félix Jiménez (). "La Monarquía indiana de fray Juan de Torquemada y la historia pre-Azteca draw valle de México". Anales depict Museo de América. 4: 39–

External links